On most informed lists of
influential early rock ‘n’ rollers, the Crew Cuts would have to rank near the
top. But Rudi Maugeri (baritone), John Perkins (lead), Ray Perkins (bass),
and Pat Barrett (tenor) weren't actually rock ‘n’ rollers in the first place:
their clean-cut, white-harmony, glee-club approach was really in the style of
early and mid-'50s “older style” vocal groups such as those “Four” groups --
the Four Aces, the Four Lads, and the Four Freshmen. The young Canadian
quartet eventually differed from those acts, however, in their concentration
upon covers of songs originally recorded by R&B / doo-wop vocal groups. Their
cover of the Chords' "Sh-Boom" set the pattern, going to number one in 1954,
and created the blueprint for their other commercially successful pop
treatments of R&B hits by the Penguins, Gene & Eunice, Otis Williams & the
Charms, the Robins, the Spaniels, the Nutmegs, and others.
Though all four had been
students under the tutelage of Mgr. John Ronan at Saint Michael’s Cathedral
Choir School, Maugeri and John Perkins were at first in a quartet called The
Jordonaires. (Elvis Presley would, later, have a back-up group with the same
name.) The other two Jordonaires later joined The Four Lads. After high
school, in 1952, Maugeri and Perkins joined Barrett and the other Perkins
brother, Ray, and called themselves the Four Tones. After a bit of success in
small clubs, and a few name changes for the group, they entered the Arthur
Godfrey Talent Hunt. Though they placed second, their jobs didn’t get any
better.
In March 1953, they worked
on a show with Gisele MacKenzie. She told her record label executives about
this terrific group, but she couldn’t remember their name. Then, (and whether
the story is true or not doesn’t matter -- it makes a great show business
story) they drove 600 miles in forty degrees below zero weather with no heat
in their car, to appear on a TV show in Cleveland. A deejay, Bill Randle,
gave them the name that stuck after he observed their short haircuts. Randle
helped them get signed with Mercury Records.
The good-looking Toronto
foursome’s first hit was one they wrote themselves, "Crazy 'Bout Ya Baby”.
But it didn’t take very long for them to find out that they were going make
more money and get more famous by covering tunes that were originally recorded
by R&B doo-wop groups. When the Crew Cuts discovered "Sh-Boom," they gave the
song a far more standard, whiter, pop treatment than the Chords had, complete
with a highly original big-band orchestration. Although the original Chords
version still became one of the first Top Ten rock ‘n’ roll hits, the Crew
Cuts' cover outsold it by a wide margin, finding a much smoother entrance into
established radio formats and much greater popularity with mainstream white
audiences. The Crew Cuts were bridging the gap between the big-band sound and
the R&B music that was sweeping the country, and they were reaping the
benefits of stardom, as well. When they were booked into a Toronto club, the
city fathers welcomed them home with a ticker-tape parade.
The Crew Cuts, with
regular visits to the Top 20 over the next couple of years, repeated the "Sh-Boom"
syndrome with songs like "Earth Angel," their second biggest hit at number
three. It was later voted the best slow dance song of the 50’s. Somewhat
sadly, nobody remembers the Crew Cuts' version today, the Penguins' original
having long established supremacy with audiences and on oldies stations. The
two versions could hardly have been more different: the Penguins used only a
piano and drums as a backup, while the Crew Cuts utilized a 16-piece big
band. However, the combinations of swing, doo-wop, R&B, and what was being
called rockabilly, created a new sound in the world of music, one that would
last forever. Dick Clark once remarked to a current Crew Cut, Bob Duncan,
“The 50’s era will never go away. It will be like the Dixieland style of the
20’s, never to pass away and always the favorite of the young and the old.”
The Crew Cuts followed
“Earth Angel” with “Gumdrop”, “Angels In the Sky”, “Mostly Martha”, and “Young
Love”. Their strategy of foraging for sources among black R&B vocal singles
was so successful it became widely imitated throughout the industry, by Pat
Boone, the McGuire Sisters, Georgia Gibbs, and numerous others. Many rock
historians point out -- with a great deal of justification -- that this
amounted to an attempt by the music establishment to buck the oncoming
threatening storm of the rock era by watering it down into a much more
palatable and conventional form that in reality had little to do with rock at
all. For a while, it worked -- the white covers frequently outsold the black
R&B originals throughout 1954 - 1956. But after Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry,
and others had staked their own claim on superstardom, it became increasingly
obvious that teenagers preferred the real article, and that the entrenchment
of authentic rock ‘n’ roll was inevitable.
Some revisionists have
claimed, dubiously, that the Crew Cuts actually helped pave the way for the
acceptance of rock in the mainstream by giving all those doo-wop songs a far
greater audience than they could have found if they were “ghettoized” in the
R&B community. After a while, however, the Crew Cuts themselves were being
widely outsold by their sources; "Young Love" (a cover, naturally, although
this time of a country classic by Sonny James) was their last Top 20 hit in
early 1957. Their Mercury hits are far more properly classified as pop vocal
outings than rock ‘n’ roll, owing much more to pre-rock harmony and band
arrangements. By 1958, they'd left Mercury for stints with RCA and other
labels and they broke up in 1964. Though they sang together very infrequently
over the ensuing years, they were honored, along with the Diamonds and the
Four Lads when they received the Juno Lifetime Achievement Award in 1984
One of the original
members, Rudi Maugeri, died in May of 2004. The remaining three appeared on a
PBS show about old-time rock ‘n’ roll that aired later in 2004.
Currently, the publicly
performing Crew Cuts are Michael Redman, Bob Duncan, Joe Dickey, and Skip
Taylor (from 1st tenor to 2nd bass, respectively). They pay homage to the
original quartet by singing the same harmonies, having fun but “behaving
themselves” on and off stage, and performing with enough verve and expertise
to garner standing ovations wherever they perform.
A long tradition
continues, at the same high level.